Home / Support for EA Modelling With eaDocX / Insights / Advice for the new modeller #3 – Fixing your meta-model

Advice for the new modeller #3 – Fixing your meta-model

Fixing your meta-model too early is bad

At a recent conference on Enterprise Architecture, we met a surprising number of people who said ‘I’ve just been made the Enterprise Architect for my Enterprise. What should I do?

These were people who looked genuinely worried, and quite right too. It’s a big job to give to someone who doesn’t know what it is. We had a steady stream of these people through the day. I wish we’d been selling counselling and not software tools.

But in the middle of all these struggling EAs was a real treat. A very smart gentleman who said – ‘I have a my Enterprise Architect Metamodel, now I need a tool to implement it”.

He expanded. “We’ve haven’t started modelling yet, but this is what we need the tool to contain.”.

Wow. So he’s about to start out doing what has to be the hardest bit of modelling there is – capturing all that’s interesting about a large organisation – and he already knows exactly what information he’ll be capturing, and how it will be organised.

We chatted for a while, gave him some brochures, and wished him well.

I’d happily bet the farm that his meta model now isn’t the one he showed us. The idea that such a complicated thing as a EA MM can be designed in advance is pure hubris.

I know this, because I fell into this bear trap.

Long ago, we had a great workshop, designing a meta-model for a project. We had modelling experts, domain experts, and even a Project manager to keep it all real. And at the end we had a MM which we all agreed would capture the essence of what we needed to model. Now just go away and populate it.

I was SO confident we’d nailed it – after all, it wasn’t the first time we’d thought about this – that I offered to customise our chosen tool to implement the MM. With Sparx EA, this is fiddly, but fairly straightforward. So a spent a couple days organising a set of diagrams, toolboxes and stereotype definitions, and it all went into an ‘MDG” file which was in effect our own modelling language. A “Meta-model in a box”.

Our team of 5 then started modelling.

We had a team stand-up every week to start with. Things were developing fast. We were discovering all kinds of new stuff about the domain, so sharing was essential. but the MM didn’t quite keep up. We needed new stereotypes, new kinds of links, and even new kinds of diagram, almost weekly. So I spent hours each week re-designing the MDG –  which contained all these new ideas – and re-releasing it to the team. This went on for about 2 months, after which I finally got tired of endless re-writes, and we decided as a team that whilst we’d DOCUMENT our MM, we’d wait until it stabilised before we committed it to code.

And finally it did stabilise. Right before the modelling was complete.

The Lesson

Don’t fix on you MM too early. And by ‘too early’ I mean before you’ve done at least one full project with a stable MM. And even then, only commit to code those bits of the MM which you haven’t changed for AGES. Keep rest as documented standards which need to be manually applied (or, if suitable tooling is available, applied in a way which you can change quickly)

If you’re on your first project – like our smart friend – then by all means document what you think your MM will be, but be prepared to change it rapidly as your model unfolds, and don’t commit it to code.

More Insights

Process Modelling with Style

25 August 2020

There may be more ways to model processes than you think

Learn More

Models matter - nearly as much as deliverables

25 August 2020

Models matter - nearly as much as deliverables

Learn More

Mechanical vs Content Quality

25 August 2020

Mechanical vs Content Quality - they are different

Learn More

Advice for the new modeller #2 - (not) Melting the Pan

25 August 2020

Advice for the new modeller #2 - (not) Melting the Pan

Learn More

Advice for the new modeller #1 - Modelling The World

25 August 2020

Advice for the new modeller #1 - Modelling The World

Learn More

Knowing when to give up

25 August 2020

Knowing when to give up makes for better Business Analysts

Learn More

Diagram Graphics for Adults

25 August 2020

Diagram Graphics for Adults

Learn More

Decision, decisions

25 August 2020

Documenting your decisions makes models more useful

Learn More

Beck's Abstraction

25 August 2020

Possibly the best model abstraction in the world

Learn More

A time for Packages

25 August 2020

A time for Packages

Learn More

Ideas in diagrams

25 August 2020

How many ideas are there in your diagrams?

Learn More

Model Driven Analysis

25 August 2020

What is it ?

Learn More

"Look at me" Diagrams

25 August 2020

"Look at me" Diagrams - and why they are usually bad

Learn More

Why we model

14 August 2020

A short argument about 'why we model' which you might want to re-use

Learn More

Model Curation techniques for EA - #1: Cleaning

14 August 2020

Cleaning your model before you let other people see it

Learn More

Model Provenence

14 August 2020

When you look at some modelling work, knowing where it came from is vital information. This article explores some ways to capture and use this

Learn More

Getting to the Point

29 July 2020

How to help your stakeholders with documents that communicate efficiently and effectively.

Learn More

The Well Dressed Model

28 July 2020

Seven ways to organise your EA models so that other people can understand them

Learn More

Choosing Your Subset

27 July 2020

One of my occasional pleasures in helping people to do better modelling is to tell them the things they DON’T need to do. And ...

Learn More

Webinar - Working with Interactive Documents

17 July 2020

This webinar from the EA Global Summit 2020 describes how to generate interactive Word documents, and use them to automate your EA model updates.

Learn More

Webinar - How to successfully scale up your EA modelling team

30 June 2020

The key issues and decisions to consider when scaling up your modelling team, and how to avoid the common pitfalls.

Learn More

Model Curation techniques for EA – 2: Navigating

16 April 2020

This is the second article in the series which describes simple techniques to improve the effectiveness of EA model sharing.

Learn More

Model Curation techniques for EA – 3: Validating

16 April 2020

So now users can find their way around successfully. The question is, what will they find when they get there?

Learn More

Explaining the General with a Specific

16 April 2020

Explaining ideas using Object diagrams

Learn More

Different documents for Different People

16 November 2018

How to tailor information to each user - making it as easy as possible for everyone to engage with your work, project or deliverables.

Learn More

Document or Model View?

21 May 2018

Use your documents as an alternative to Model Views.

Learn More

Color your Knowledge

25 April 2018

A while ago a client asked me to look at some process diagrams which had been created for them by a well-known consultancy.

Learn More

Model Curation

6 March 2018

How cleaning, navigating and validating your EA model makes sharing and collaborating much more effective.

Learn More

Context - Where are we?

20 October 2017

I’m occasionally asked “What’s the most re-usable bit of a model – where should I start?“.

Learn More

Glossary

12 October 2017

In a recent talk, I asked the audience of about 100 BAs which of them maintained a glossary as part of their work.

Learn More

Hard and Soft

11 October 2017

No, not about Brexit… More about styles of Business Analyst.

Learn More

Printing connectors

18 October 2016

Creating documents that start with the connections between the things in your model

Learn More

Using Multi-hop relationships to display Branch/Merge with EA13

11 August 2016

One of the most common requests we see from new EA users is: "Why can’t I do branch/merge with EA?

Learn More

Compare pricing and features

Choose the eaDocX edition that’s right for you and your team

Compare Pricing

Download a free trial

Take a free, no obligation, 30-day trial of eaDocX. Discover for yourself why it’s the world’s best-selling Enterprise Architect extension.

Download